What Red Bull, Nespresso, Aldi — and behavioural science — can teach us about brand framing and context over content

  • Treatment A, which would save 200 lives.
  • Treatment B, which had a 33 per cent chance of saving everyone and a 66 per cent chance of saving nobody.
  • Red Bull reframed sugary, caffeinated, carbonated beverages as energy drinks, allowing them to charge much more money for much less liquid than Coke.
  • Nespresso reframed coffee pods (75c/serve) as cheaper than coffee out ($4.50/serve) rather than more expensive than instant coffee at home ($0.12/serve).
  • Aldi reframed the entire grocery market with their ‘we’re not cheap, they’re expensive’ strategic platform.
  1. Can we frame the same attribute more positively?
    This one might seem obvious, given that our jobs tend to be about ‘accentuating the positives’, but it works.
    Often, there are multiple options for positive framing and the challenge is working out which stage to play on. Do we want to be the healthiest snack in the confectionery aisle, or the tastiest treat in the health food aisle? Are we better off building a brand that’s the best Vodka from New Zealand, or the most New Zealand vodka in the world?
  2. I remember seeing an ad last year for Berocca that positioned the product as what you take to be ready for a big day ahead, rather than what you take to recover from a big night out. This is a prime example of more positive framing in action.
  3. Can a benefit be framed in terms of losses rather than gains?
    There’s a large body of research (also from the field of Behavioural Science) that demonstrates humans are far more motivated to avoid losses than to pursue equivalent gains. This makes sense from an evolutionary perspective where, for most of human history, gaining an extra day’s worth of food was a nice bonus but losing today’s meal would have been a disaster. For this reason, framing benefits as ‘avoided losses’ can be far more powerful than framing them as gains.
  4. Research by Simon Gächter in 2009 looked at registration fees that included either penalties for late payments or discounts for early ones. Despite the amounts payable being identical, late fees resulted in 93 per cent of people paying on time (avoiding a loss) while early discounts were only taken up by 67 per cent (getting a gain).
  5. In the VC world, funders will often consider whether a fledgling startup is positioning itself as more ‘aspirin’ or ‘multivitamin’, knowing that consumers are willing to pay more for the former (get me back to normal) than the latter (take me somewhere new and amazing).
  6. How far up the ladder can we go?
    There’s no question that all advertising is designed to reframe perceptions, but in my experience, there’s a distinct hierarchy to consider. At a minimum, comms should reframe the way somebody feels about a product (‘oh wow, now it’s got folate!’).
  7. The next rung up is reframing the way somebody feels about a brand. For example, the recent Crocs collab with Justin Bieber has lifted demand across the entire Crocs portfolio, not just the limited edition (yet still unsightly) Bieber edition.
    The third rung up is reframing an entire category. This is usually achieved by pointing out that until now, people have been shopping it all wrong, and that in addition to ‘price vs quality’, there’s a whole new dimension to consider. Who Gives a Crap added ‘social impact’ to toilet paper. Virgin added ‘fun’ to air travel. Suzuki is doing the same to cars.
  8. Which brings us to the final rung — reframing the way people feel about themselves. It appears that the thread running through almost every case study that’s become too much of a trope to share, is the way it’s changed people’s perceptions of themselves. Nike (‘maybe I am an athlete?’), Dove (‘maybe I am beautiful?’), Apple (‘maybe I am creative?’) — I’m looking at you.
  9. Deciding which rung to play at will impact everything, from the tone and language used to the budget required to get the job done.

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Hardhat

Hardhat

We’re an independent creative agency helping brands capitalise on the why, when, where, what and how of human behaviour.